Quite recently I have been playing Persona 5, and man am I in love with this game. This game has taken the title of best game for me quite handily. Sony seems to be eager to come out of the gate swinging with some very polished games. First it was Horizon: Zero Dawn, now it’s Persona 5. And given some of the exclusives we have to look forward to in the future, I am excited to see what happens next. The thing to know about this game is that it is DRIPPING with a style all its own. The punk aesthetic, vibrant colors, and jazzy soundtrack all mesh so well in immersing me in this world. I feel like each of the Palace worlds was a place that I would at least like to see once. Style was oozing out of every pore in that game, and bless it for that.
We live in an age where it sees like every game company is looking to go more and more into the realms of realism. Seems like there is an arms race to get past the uncanny valley of a game that looks so real that I can’t tell the difference between it and reality. However, there are pros and cons to both sides of that. This is something that is being lost on people. Let’s dive into this and show these elements in respect to one-another.
When I think of games that have embraced realism so heavily, two that come to mind immediately are The Last of Us and Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End. Both games had incredible detail put into every element. Naughty Dog has gotten something of a pedigree for games that are insanely detailed and have characters who feel believable. This could only be possible with effects that fight that Uncanny Valley I mentioned earlier. I could get lost in every environment in those games. They were visual masterpieces, which I can and do replay over and over just for how beautiful it is to go through.
There is also the element when you are looking to capture how grim something is. A war, for example, can be brought to life much more horrifically when you bring it into the realistic space. Fear is also more palpable. I played the PT demo like some of you, and holy shit! The realistic nature of that is what made it so unnerving to play. I had the shit getting scared out of me because it felt like I was really in that hallway, with that ghost who was after me. And fuck that telephone! Gave me a fucking heart-attack. It’s hard to imagine such a game being done any other way. Although, Silent Hill 4 did the concept pretty decently, for the part of the game where you are trapped in the main character’s apartment.
Style allows a game world to feel unique. When you want to create an atmosphere in a game, it helps when you have a universe where the rules of it feel unique. As a frame of reference, let’s take a look at Persona 5. This game is about youthful rebellion against authoritarian rule-making. Every element goes along with this. The vibrant use of colors in every regard, even the menus, makes you see this aesthetic. Like watching a punk rock music video from the 90’s, and with the jazzy soundtrack to boot. Everything goes towards making you feel like this world is all its own. Plus, the style helps tell the stories of the protagonists.
Another game which had a unique style to see it was Life is Strange. While the ending to that game was bullshit, it was still pretty awesome to play. Part of this was because the style felt like a teen comic. While the facial animations could most definitely used a lot of work, you still get invested because these characters have personality that goes along with the soft colors and pastel look. It’s a game which uses that aesthetic to compel you to slow down, take your time, and investigate things.
Then it can be something that assists gameplay. Look at Mirror’s Edge for that. The world of that game was drenched in white. It made the colors in it stand out so you knew to pay attention to them. Not to mention that it made the authoritarian nature of the government more apparently. The world is white, they are always in black and blue. Their color tells you how you should see them. It’s not the most complicated method of story-telling, but it gets the job done.
Something that you also have to keep in mind is that style is easier to do. Games that go for realism take longer to get right. And in a gaming market where people are demanding games quicker (I have no idea why. I have no problem with delays to get it right), this ends up with a TON of bugs. Style has no such limitations. It can be done much quicker and use a smaller budget. Which brings me to the cons.
There is something to keep in mind when you have games shooting for that Uncanny Valley – they have a bad habit of having bugs. A TON of bugs. And with the rush I said before, more and more games are being shipped with bugs that the industry calls “known shippable.” Hell, when Naughty Dog was working on Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception, they found a bug in the game just three days before shipping that would have crashed the PS3 console. Thankfully they were able to patch it in time, but you see what I mean? Going more and more real means that if you don’t want a game to have a shit-ton of bugs, you have to devote more and more time to it. For me, that’s fine. I wish more developers would take the time to hold back and get it right. If anything, that is rewarded with player loyalty as we feel the developers want to take the time to make us happy. Granted, that can go both ways. Just look at the backlash with all the delays of Mighty No. 9.
Another thing is that games that shoot for that point are often pretty ugly. People complain that games have way too much gray and brown in them, well, that’s part of the fact that they are shooting for realism. Most apartments have white walls and tan carpets. Most cities are gray and dismal. Not everywhere can be Seattle or Tokyo. So your palate of colors gets very limited the more realistic you shoot for.
The biggest problem with a game that has a unique style is that you are almost certainly condemning it to be niche. Remember all the games I listed above? From Persona 5 to Mirror’s Edge, one thing they have in common is that they don’t appeal to a mass market. There are so many games I can think of with a fascinating unique style. Flower, ABZU, The Wolf Among Us, Journey, Borderlands, and one thing they all have in common is that they are niche. Borderlands is the most mainstream, but even it doesn’t have the mass draw that other games do. For whatever reason, people are just drawn more to the realism side of the spectrum. Something I will never understand.
Then there’s the fact that the Uncanny Valley of facial animation is lost on you. Without exception, it’s gone. With realism they can use motion capture tech, and it is getting better and better at making facial animations that look like real people. Stylization has that concept forever beyond its reach. After all, if the feature of a character are off from normal people, you can’t believe that they are real when they talk. It’s like how a cartoon can have good lip-synching, but you still know it’s a cartoon. That’s just how it goes. But that’s no excuse to skimp on the facial animations. I’m talking to you, Life is Strange. So many of the more emotional scenes in that game would have been better if we could see the character’s emotions better.
So, which side are you? Let me know in the comments.
Until next time, a quote,
“Style – all who have it share one thing: originality.” – Diana Vreeland